We’ve all taken pastoral leadership courses.
Or maybe you brought home a notebook stuffed full of principles from a leadership conference.
Who knows? You’re probably like me and have bookshelves in your office dedicated to pastoral leadership resources.
Some of these have titles that hold great promise. They use phrases like…
Breaking Through Barriers
Leading the Church Through Change
Maximize Your Leadership Potential
How to Be an Effective Leader
Leadership that Results in Growth
Wonderful resources.
So much of quality pastoral leadership depends on whether you have a plan or not. Have you thought through a strategy for church outreach, growth, health, finance and so much more.
I like plans. I like strategy. I much, much prefer to work that way.
But I feel like I need to offer a counter-balance to so much of the emphasis on pastoral leadership today.
It’s simply this…
You Don’t Have To Have It All Figured Out.
You don’t always HAVE to have an intricate, elaborate plan for outreach and more.
I got to be honest with you. I’m not sure the apostle Paul had as much of a well-tailored plan as I once might have suspected. I’d argue Paul was the greatest exponent of the Christian faith in the New Testament (outside of Jesus, of course).
It was through Paul’s missionary efforts that the gospel largely spread outside of Jerusalem and into the Gentile world.
Paul was a master leader, church-planter and biblical teacher who left an incredible mark on Christianity that is still being felt today.
No one would argue with the fact that he was one of the greatest leaders of people in human history.
So, that being the case, you would naturally assume Paul must have been a master strategist. To have the kind of empire-wide, generational-changing influence that he held he must have had a tremendous plan.
Maybe a five year church growth plan. Or a ten year gospel immersion strategy.
But if you read Acts 16:1-10, every time Paul put together a plan of action, God seemed to change it. And finally, God said, “Paul, chuck your plan. Forget your five year strategy. This is the new direction I want you to go.”
And once Paul did that, the ministry exploded. It soared to a level that Paul never could have imagined. But it wasn’t because of Paul’s plan. In fact, the growth in the churches was a direct result of Paul DEVIATING from his plan.
Read Acts 16.
Paul preaches in Derbe. He preaches in Lystra. He traveled from town to town.
Then it says that Paul and his team traveled throughout Phrygia and Galatia. But then it says something very strange to many of our ears.
It says, “The Holy Spirit kept them from preaching in the province of Asia.” Then it also mentions that the Holy Spirit would not allow them to enter Bithynia.
Paul’s plan was to go into the province of Asia. Paul’s plan was to preach in Bithynia.
That’s wasn’t God’s plan.
What happens next?
Paul has a vision! A man from Macedonia urges him to come there and help them.
That’s when everything becomes unhinged.
That’s When Everything…I Mean Everything, Changes.
Paul never planned to go that direction. But the Macedonian ministry and churches become a colossal game-changer.
Thessalonica, Philipi, Berea and much more… these were the churches on the other side of the pond. They were the Macedonian churches. It was THIS CHANGE that broke open Paul’s ministry.
I think what we learn from this episode is a very important principle.
Paul did not have an elaborate strategy… but God did. A big part of pastoral leadership is not so much having all the answers, but being willing to change your plan when God directs it.
I’m a planner. I’m a schedule type of person.
I have a weekly schedule and routine.
I know what my average Monday is going to look like.
I can tell you what I’ll be doing on Thursday afternoons.
I like schedules. It makes me much more efficient and effective in pastoral leadership.
But just remember this…
Be lead by the Holy Spirit, not enslaved by your day-planner.
At times God will detour you from your plan. When that happens, rejoice. His strategy is always better than yours.
It is better to be prayerful and not have a clue than having a plan to follow that is not of God.
That’s worth repeating.
It’s better to be prayerful and NOT have a clue than to have a plan to follow that is NOT of God.
Remember That. It Will Make You Very Effective At Pastoral Leadership.
So let’s review.
Please do not read this and think, “Randall said to forget ministry plans. We should flush our strategies and stop thinking intentionally.”
That’s not the point of this article on pastoral leadership.
The point is – and we don’t always hear this in seminary or read this in our leadership books – you don’t have to have it all figured out.
Sure, develop a plan. Be wise. Be intentional. Implement smart strategy.
But be flexible enough to follow when God changes the plan. Because any changes he makes, even if they’re last minute changes, are definitely improvements.
Wise leaders – the ones who truly understand pastoral leadership – follow this principle and flourish.
Drop me a comment below to let me know what you thought about this post…
Your Sermon Coach,
Randall Garing






